Last Friday, in a press conference addressing poor reception issues stemming from antenna placement with their new iPhone 4, Apple tried to shuck blame for the snafu by pointing out that other phone manufacturers have some of the same problems. Now, these same manufacturers are striking back at Apple.
As part of his impromptu press conference, Apple CEO Steve Jobs pointed out that other phones suffered from these same issues, even exhibiting video that showed reception problems with people holding BlackBerry, Android, and Windows phones in certain ways, all of which diminished reception and resulted in dropped calls (since known as the ‘iPhone death grip’).
However, early this week after the Apple ‘antenna-gate’ announcement, the other phone manufacturers mentioned by Jobs are refuting his claims. Nokia was first, saying in an email message that antenna performance can be affected by a tight grip, but added: “that’s why Nokia designs our phones to ensure acceptable performance in all real-life cases, for example when the phone is held in either hand.”
BlackBerry manufacturer Research In Motion (RIM) followed with a stronger, albeit less snarky response, saying that “Apple’s claims about RIM products appear to be deliberate attempts to distort the public’s understanding of an antenna design issue and to deflect attention from Apple’s difficult situation.” Ouch.
Yesterday, smart phone manufacturer HTC (of recent Evo fame) said that they have had similar problems with one of their phones, the Droid Eris, but got complaints from only about .016 percent of customers, far lower than the nearly .6 percent of customers complaining about the same issues on Apple’s iPhone 4.
When the dust settles, it is unclear whether Apple will be all that damaged by the reception issues fallout, or if their competitors such as RIM, HTC, or Nokia will have gained much ground on what’s still considered to be the best smart phone on the market. But what is clear, looking at these comments, is that neither side is going down without a fight.






